D4s image quality - ISO still short of the Df!

Featured Wednesday, 12 March 2014 03:15

The D4s has just been tested, with surprising results.

 When the Nikon D4 came out - it was a BIG advance over the D3s. The ISO performance was significantly better - and it instantly became the top rated 35mm DSLR sensor tested by DXOmark - until the D800 came out!

A few years later, and a few models passed, the D4s is now on the street and, as the official Nikon press release states, it has "A new 16.23 image sensor specifically matched to the new EXPEED 4 image processor delivers stunning images that exhibit even greater sharpness and enhanced depth" and they claim "...unrivalled low light performance."

We are all fairly accustomed to bold claims at release right, but how would it stack up in reality? DXOmark have tested it - and whilst I know a lot of folks question the testing methods (Nikon cameras tend to perform best), and of course technical performance is only part of overall quality of a camera - the results can still be compared side by side.

First off the bat - it exceeds the Canon flagship 1Dx in every category tested. However, it ends up with the same score as the camera it replaces - the Nikon D4. As the tables below show, whilst the D4 and D4s both scored 89, it has improved in ISO slightly(3074 vs 2965) - but it scores LOWER for colour depth.

The interesting thing is that the much maligned Nikon Df still outperforms them all in ISO performance - by 200 points - double the improvement the D4s offers over the D4.

sensors

D4s vs 1Dx

Images from DXOmark

As I said above - these ratings are only a small part of the story. I seriously doubt that a few points improvement in ISO performance is enough for anyone to upgrade, or change systems. Ergonomics, focus capabilities, battery life and rugged build time are (to me) far more important aspects when considering a sports camera like the D4s & 1Dx. What do you think? Share your thoughts on the Community Forum thread HERE.

That said, for those who DON'T need ultimate speed and the other benefits a big $6,000 camera offer, but who DO want amazing ISO performance... the Df may just be the way to go. I will be doing a follow up review on that, after several months of ownership, very soon.

DigitalRev discount - Limited Offer!

Share:

Leave a comment

Sony a6400 Complete Auto Focus, ISO & Time Lapse Testing

Sony a6400 Complete Auto Focus, ISO & Time Lapse Testing

Sunday, 03 February 2019 13:51

Sony claim the a6400 has the 'Worlds Fastest Autofocus' - and my first video split people - so here is my COMPLETE AF testing.

Read more...
3 Stop ND Filters Compared - $5 to $180

3 Stop ND Filters Compared - $5 to $180

Monday, 28 January 2019 21:41

Huge range in sharpness, color and vignetting on these 3 stop filters...

Read more...
50mm Showdown - f1.1 to f1.4 - $350 to $4,000 - M Mount

50mm Showdown - f1.1 to f1.4 - $350 to $4,000 - M Mount

Sunday, 20 January 2019 10:20

Comparing the 7 Artisans f1.1 $350 lens to the f1.1 Voigtlander, f1.4 Nikkor (adapted) and the $4,000 f1.4 Leica Summilux.

Read more...
10 Stop ND Filters Compared - $10 to $360

10 Stop ND Filters Compared - $10 to $360

Wednesday, 02 January 2019 22:54

I compare 15 filters, with a range of prices from $10 to $360 - and a big variation in build quality, color cast, sharpness and vignetting - it is worth seeing some real world results before buying anything.I compare 15 filters, with a range of prices from $10 to $360 - and a big variation in build quality, color cast, sharpness and vignetting - it is worth seeing some real world results before buying anything.

Read more...
Best & Worst of 2018 - Cameras, lenses, trends & more...

Best & Worst of 2018 - Cameras, lenses, trends & more...

Monday, 24 December 2018 23:14

 

2018 has been an epic year with some fantastic new gear announced - and some pretty crap stuff too! In this video I take you through my picks for the best, worst and most disappointing gear and trends of the year!

Read more...
Nikon Z7 vs D850 - What should you buy?

Nikon Z7 vs D850 - What should you buy?

Monday, 03 December 2018 19:46

The D850 is the culmination of decades of SLR refinement - the Z7 is the companies first full frame mirrorless - but it costs even more!

Read more...
Fujifilm X-T3 - Complete Review - World's Best APSC Camera?

Fujifilm X-T3 - Complete Review - World's Best APSC Camera?

Monday, 26 November 2018 17:01

This thing destroys the competition in many ways - GH5 beaten for video and ergonomics and the fuji optics are up there with the best of full frame!

Read more...
Canon EOS R - Studio Portraiture Review

Canon EOS R - Studio Portraiture Review

Sunday, 28 October 2018 12:32

The good, The Bad, and the Stupid....

Read more...
Nikon Z lenses - are they better than F Mount?

Nikon Z lenses - are they better than F Mount?

Saturday, 27 October 2018 12:47

Nikon has been promoting the larger diameter and shorter flange distance of the Z mount, and how this will allow more lens designs, easier design, better optics, faster AF and edge to edge sharpness. But are they actually better?

Read more...